None of This Is True Summary By Chapter | Lisa Jewell

Chapter 5: The Pitch at Stitch (Tuesday, 18 June)

Alix visits “Stitch” and brings two dresses for alterations, feeling odd when Josie touches her during the fitting.

While Alix is in the changing cubicle, Josie proposes a podcast about someone currently changing their life.

She tells Alix that her own story is “extraordinary” and involves a traumatic marriage.

Alix feels repelled by Josie’s intensity but is also drawn to the journalistic potential of the story.

She agrees to meet Josie for coffee the next day to discuss the project further.

Josie spends the afternoon spending Nathan’s money on luxury items to soothe her marital resentment.

Josie stares at herself in the mirror, feeling like a “shape‑shifter” ready to emerge.

Key Moment: Josie officially pitches her life story as a podcast subject to Alix.

New Information: Josie has been with Walter since she was fifteen and feels her life has been in stasis for thirty years.

Chapter 6: The First Professional Meeting (Wednesday, 19 June)

Alix and Josie meet at a trendy coffee shop to discuss the format of the podcast, and Alix suggests calling it *Hi! I’m Your Birthday Twin!*.

Josie is mesmerized by Alix’s professional world and agrees to a test recording session at Alix’s house.

Walter questions Josie about her whereabouts when she returns, but she lies about seeing a school mother.

Josie is terrified Walter will find out about the project and talk her out of it.

Alix prepares her home studio, feeling torn between Nathan’s generosity and his failures.

Josie arrives with her little dog, Fred, in a shoulder bag.

The two women prepare to dive into Josie’s past.

Key Moment: Alix commits to the project and titles it *Hi! I’m Your Birthday Twin!*.

New Information: Walter had “business with social services” regarding the girls in the past.

Chapter 7: First Recording (Thursday, 20 June)

During the first session, Josie reveals she met Walter when she was thirteen and he was forty.

She describes his interest in her as an “invisible monster” in the room that only she could see.

Alix is internally shocked by the revelation of grooming but maintains a professional demeanor.

Josie admits she was obsessed with the idea of him despite being scared.

A documentary segment features Josie’s school friend, Helen, who describes Josie as odd and controlling.

Helen notes that after Josie’s fourteenth birthday, she “disappeared” into a world with an old man.

Josie walks home and steals a Nespresso pod from Alix’s studio as a “trophy” of glamour.

Key Moment: Josie admits to her teenage relationship with Walter, shocking Alix.

New Information: Walter was forty‑one when he began his relationship with fifteen‑year‑old Josie.

Chapter 8: Nathan’s First Bender (Thursday, 20 June – Night)

Nathan fails to come home by his promised 7 P.M. deadline, triggering Alix’s dread.

She texts and calls him, but he doesn’t answer and her messages remain unread.

Alix sits in her studio with a glass of wine, listening back to Josie’s disturbing interview.

She feels a “tiny prickle of excitement” about the darkness of the story she is uncovering.

Feeling lonely and stressed, she sends Josie a warm message late at night.

Josie reads the message with “childish delight,” feeling a crush‑like connection to Alix.

Nathan eventually replies at 6 A.M. the next morning, claiming he blacked out at Giovanni’s flat.

Key Moment: Alix realizes the profound potential of Josie’s dark story while Nathan is missing.

New Information: Nathan’s benders are frequent enough that Alix knows the “dreadful inevitability” of his absence.

Chapter 9: Despair and Inquiries (Friday, 21 June)

Alix handles the children’s school run after only four hours of sleep, fueled by rage at Nathan.

She visits the school office and asks Mandy, the manager, if she remembers the Fair sisters.

Mandy describes the Fairs as a “strange family” with many prove‑less issues.

She reveals that Erin once came to school with a broken arm and blamed her sister, Roxy.

Mandy recalls Walter as a “big man” with a “big temper” and Josie as “odd” and blank.

Nathan continues to message Alix, promising it will never happen again.

Meanwhile, Josie prepares baby food for Erin and liquefies leftovers for her reclusive daughter.

Key Moment: Mandy reveals the Fair family’s history of violence and social service intervention.

New Information: Roxy was “wild” and suspected of breaking her sister’s arm, while Erin was quiet and possibly autistic.

Chapter 10: The Stalker in the Park (Sunday, 23 June)

Josie takes her dog Fred for a walk and finds herself subconsciously drawn toward Alix’s road.

She observes Alix’s house, noting the white shutters and milky‑blue door.

Josie watches Alix and her sisters, Zoe and Maxine, return home with their children, looking tanned and happy.

She feels a visceral pang of jealousy for Alix’s “extraordinary” and loud family life.

After the family enters the house, Josie crosses the street and plucks a passionflower from Alix’s front wall.

She carries the stolen flower home as if it were a talisman of the life she wants.

Nathan has been “extra nice” since his last bender, early for dinner and helping with the kids.

Key Moment: Josie loiters outside Alix’s home and steals a flower from her garden.

New Information: Josie is actively stalking Alix’s domestic life to find “glimmers” of her existence.

Chapter 11: The Estate Visit (Tuesday, 25 June)

Alix visits the council estate where Josie grew up to interview her mother, Pat O’Neill.

Pat appears glamorous and vibrant, but Alix quickly identifies her as a “raging narcissist.”

Pat expresses clear disdain for Josie, describing her birth as “terrifying” and Josie as a difficult child.

She claims Josie “subsumed” her life and ambitions.

Josie remains stiff and unanimated in her mother’s presence, making tea while Pat boasts about her community work.

Alix realizes that no child of a narcissist like Pat could make it out into the world “unscathed.”

Josie is furious with her mother for being “terrible” to her.

Key Moment: Alix witnesses the toxic dynamic between Josie and her mother, Pat.

New Information: Pat was twenty and in denial during her pregnancy; she felt “terrified” when she first saw Josie.

Chapter 12: The Theft and the Husband (Wednesday, 26 June)

Josie arrives at Alix’s house and meets Nathan for the first time, finding him “rough and raw.”

She feels a surge of fury when Nathan jokes about her dog.

During the recording, Josie recounts escaping her mother’s judgment on her fifteenth birthday to find Walter at his cabin.

She describes accepting a shot of vodka and a kiss, knowing she was “leaving this world” for his.

After the session, Josie steals a bottle of expensive hand wash from Alix’s downstairs toilet.

She tucks it into her drawer next to the Nespresso pod, relishing the way it “smells like Alix.”

Alix notices the missing soap later and questions Nathan, who dismisses it as a kid’s mistake.

Key Moment: Josie steals a bottle of Alix’s hand wash, intensifying her “trophy” collection.

New Information: Josie describes her relationship with Walter as “befriending the monster.”

Chapter 13: The Rain and the Apparition (Saturday, 29 June)

During a heavy rainstorm, Alix encounters Josie standing in the street near a birthday party.

Josie appears dazed and claims she “couldn’t get her feet to work” after seeing Alix with her daughter.

Alix tries to help her into a café, but Josie suddenly disappears when Alix goes to the counter to buy cookies.

Josie returns home soaked to the bone and shivers in bed.

She believes she saw her missing daughter, Roxy, through a window and panicked.

Walter cares for her, bringing her food while she listens to Alix’s podcast to wash away the “black noise.”

Josie sends Alix a message apologizing for the “deliria” caused by a summer cold.

Key Moment: Josie’s mental instability is highlighted when she vanishes from the café.

New Information: Josie believes she saw Roxy, who has been missing for five years.

Chapter 14: Recovery and Messages (Monday, 1 July)

Josie returns to work at “Stitch” despite Walter’s protestations that she should rest.

She listens to music to block out the buzz of the shop and her own chaotic thoughts.

She exchanges friendly messages with Alix, confirming their next recording session.

Josie feels a “rightness and certainty” returning to her senses.

Alix is beginning to feel the intensity of the project and its effect on her own domestic life.

Nathan continues to be early for dinner and helpful, though Alix’s trust remains fragile.

Josie’s obsession with Alix’s “perfect” life grows as she prepares to share more of her past.

Key Moment: Josie reaffirms her connection to Alix, preparing for deeper revelations.

New Information: Walter is retired and spends his time reading news online and emailing his estranged family in Canada.

Chapter 15: Walter’s Marriage Secrets (Tuesday, 2 July)

During their next session, Josie admits that Walter was married with two sons when they began their affair.

She claims she didn’t find out he was married until she was eighteen, despite him living with his family in Essex on weekends.

Alix drives Josie home and observes the shabby exterior of her flat, which contrasts with Josie’s idealized descriptions.

She watches Josie and Walter through the window and is taken aback by how old and worn Walter looks.

Alix tries to search for the Fairs online afterward but finds them virtually anonymous on the internet.

She scrolls through Street View, looking for something she can’t quite identify.

Josie feels like a “shape‑shifter” as she considers changing her style to mimic Alix.

Key Moment: Alix gets her first look at Josie’s actual living environment and the aging Walter.

New Information: Walter was living a double life for years during his initial relationship with Josie.

Chapter 16: The Makeover and Jewelry (Thursday, 4 July)

Josie discards her lucky denim jacket for a black shirt and meets Alix for a shopping trip.

They visit an expensive boutique where Alix helps Josie choose several stylish dresses.

Josie spends nearly four hundred pounds, a celebratory moment that makes her feel shapely and young.

Alix hugs Josie, a gesture that feels strange and new to Josie.

However, as she returns home, Josie steals a gold bracelet with diamond droplets from Alix’s console table.

She kisses the bracelet and hides it in her underwear drawer.

Josie also begins sending Alix cryptic “strong woman” memes to encourage Alix to leave Nathan.

Key Moment: Josie steals Alix’s birthday bracelet, a significant personal violation.

New Information: Josie has savings of about nine thousand pounds and feels she is “refreshing her life.”

Chapter 17: Neighborly Gossip (Friday, 5 July)

Alix encounters her neighbor’s son, Harry, who remembers the Fair sisters from school.

Harry describes Roxy as “insane” and “scary,” while Erin was the “weirdest person” he ever met.

He mentions rumors of abuse and the fact that Erin only ate soft food.

This confirms Alix’s suspicions about the dark nature of the Fair household.

Josie returns to the spot where she thought she saw Roxy, hoping for another glimpse.

She feels an emptiness when she doesn’t see her daughter but finds relief in the solitude.

Josie then goes to Alix’s house while the family is out, peering through the shutters and stealing a magazine.

Key Moment: Harry confirms the deep‑seated “dark stuff” surrounding the Fair girls’ home life.

New Information: Roxy was seen as aggressive and “scary” at school, while Erin was notably emaciated.

Chapter 18: Spying on the Summers (Saturday, 6 July – Day)

Josie loiters on Alix’s doorstep, staring through the windows and checking the recycling.

She finds a glossy interiors magazine called *Livingetc* and steals it.

Later, Nathan shows Alix the Ring doorbell app footage of Josie loitering.

They watch Josie loom in and out of the camera’s shot, peering through the shutters for an uncomfortable amount of time.

They are bewildered to see her rifling through their recycling and stealing the magazine.

Alix says, “Oh my God,” feeling simultaneously thrilled and terrified by Josie’s behavior.

She realizes she has brought a “pure stranger” into her inner life.

Key Moment: Alix and Nathan discover Josie’s stalking behavior via their security camera.

New Information: Josie has been collecting “trophies” from Alix’s recycling bin.

Chapter 19: Evidence Found (Saturday, 6 July – Night)

Alix attends a dinner party with Nathan and his friends, feeling uneasy as the drinking accelerates.

She leaves early in an Uber to get back for the babysitter and, emboldened by drink, messages Josie about the Ring camera footage.

Josie replies immediately, claiming she was “just passing” and didn’t mean to worry her.

Josie is at home, reading the stolen magazine and making a list of luxury items she wants to buy.

She finds a paper receipt from Alix’s birthday inside the magazine and kisses it.

This small scrap of Alix’s life feels “magical” and weighted with fortune to Josie.

Walter is missing from his side of the bed, which Josie tries to ignore.

Key Moment: Alix confronts Josie about her doorstep behavior, but Josie deflects with an innocuous reply.

New Information: Josie has a “Pinterest page” for inspirational quotes about being single.

Chapter 20: The Denim Theory (Monday, 8 July)

During a session, Josie explains her obsession with denim, revealing that a denim jacket was central to her early “love affair” with Walter.

Walter once told her the jacket was “just you,” making her believe it was a lucky charm that held his affection.

Alix examines old photos of a young, handsome Walter and feels a sick swoop in her stomach.

She realizes that even though he was a groomer, he was conventionally attractive then.

Josie admits she would tell her thirteen‑year‑old self to “run for the hills.”

After the recording, Alix confides in Josie that Nathan has a drinking problem and goes on “benders.”

Josie appears shocked and asks if he cheats, which Alix vehemently denies.

Key Moment: Alix admits Nathan’s alcoholism to Josie, giving her a weapon to use against him.

New Information: Walter was once a “hunk” with big strong forearms and shiny hair.

Chapter 21: The Slap (Tuesday, 9 July)

Josie arrives at Alix’s house uninvited, wearing one of her new boutique dresses.

She confronts Alix about whether she loves Nathan and asks if Alix would feel “free” if he died.

Alix admits that while life might be easier, Nathan’s death would make her feel “sad,” not “free.”

This admission visibly disappoints Josie, cooling the atmosphere between them.

Later at home, Walter questions Josie about the “school mum” again.

Josie, feeling “darkness” falling upon her, snaps and slaps Walter violently across the face.

She screams “I FUCKING HATE YOU” at him twice before he silently returns to his computer.

Key Moment: Josie’s latent violence is revealed when she attacks Walter in their flat.

New Information: Pat warns Alix that Josie is as “bad” as Walter and to be careful.

Part II

Chapter 22: Dinner Invitation (Wednesday, 10 July)

Alix decides to invite Josie and Walter over for dinner to “move the project along.”

She hopes to get Walter’s side of the story in a social setting with alcohol.

Nathan reluctantly agrees to be there as a “man’s man” for Walter.

Josie is thrilled by the invitation and forces Walter to get a haircut and new clothes from Primark.

She feels like she is “smashing through invisible walls” toward the truth.

At work, Josie plans her outfit and pictures a perfect evening in Alix’s kitchen.

Alix asks Josie to bring a photo of her daughters to their next session.

Key Moment: Alix initiates the disastrous dinner invitation that leads to the final escalation.

New Information: Walter has an “elastic relationship with the truth” according to his own claims.

Chapter 23: Family Photos (Thursday, 11 July)

Josie shows Alix photos of Roxy and Erin as toddlers and then as troubled teenagers.

Roxy is shown with multiple facial piercings, while Erin appears stony‑faced and emaciated.

Alix is shocked by the transformation and the “dead eyes” of the girls.

Josie reveals that Walter worked away in the North East during the week, leaving her and the girls “free.”

She claims Walter’s return on weekends would change the happy atmosphere for the worse.

Walter returns from the barber looking much the same, much to Josie’s disappointment.

Josie tells Walter she plans to tell Alix “everything” about what they did.

Key Moment: Josie threatens to reveal their “dirty little secret” to Alix, causing a major row with Walter.

New Information: Walter was potentially a protector who helped monetize Erin’s gaming, contrary to Josie’s abuse claims.

Chapter 24: The Dinner Disaster (Friday, 12 July)

The dinner at the Summers’ is a complete failure as Nathan doesn’t show up until nearly 9 P.M., heavily intoxicated.

Walter and Josie sit in awkward silence with Alix, who is visibly stressed and sharp.

During a private moment in the studio, Walter warns Alix that Josie is a “control freak” who invents her own reality.

Josie overhears this conversation and is filled with “red‑hot fury.”

She publicly insults Nathan’s drinking and calls his behavior “disgusting.”

The night ends with Josie and Walter leaving in a “horrendous” atmosphere.

Back home, Josie screams at Walter and calls him a “pedophile,” feeling the universe fragmenting.

Key Moment: Walter warns Alix about Josie’s delusions while Josie secretly listens.

New Information: Leon saw Josie standing outside the studio window looking “really, really cross” during Walter’s warning.

Chapter 25: The Escape and Entry (Saturday, 13 July)

Josie arrives at Alix’s door at 3 A.M. with a bloodied face and a split lip, claiming Walter attacked her.

She tells Alix that Erin tried to intervene and was also hit before fleeing to a friend’s house.

Alix, feeling guilty about Nathan’s absence, allows Josie to stay in her spare room.

Nathan returns later that morning, shocked to see Josie in Alix’s pajamas.

Josie confronts Nathan, telling him he should be a “better husband” and blaming his absence for her “attack.”

Alix feels a growing sense of unease and wonders if Josie’s “weirdness” is innate or a trauma response.

Josie hides a blood‑smeared key with the number “6” under her mattress.

Key Moment: Josie successfully moves into Alix’s home by faking a domestic violence incident.

New Information: Josie has a “plan” for Nathan and has stolen a key from her flat.

Chapter 26: Staying Long‑Term (Sunday, 14 July)

Alix informs Josie that her sister is coming to stay on Saturday and that Josie will need to leave the guest room.

Josie agrees but feels safe staying with Alix until then.

During their session, Josie reveals she hasn’t seen Erin’s face in months, feeding her only baby food through a door.

She claims Walter has been sexually abusing Erin for five years while Josie wore earplugs.

Alix is horrified and questions why Josie never went to the police or protected her child.

Josie rationalizes her inaction as being “trapped” by a monster, but Alix suspects the story has “plot holes.”

Josie sends Alix a “strong woman” meme to further isolate her from Nathan.

Key Moment: Josie accuses Walter of incestuous abuse to secure Alix’s deep sympathy.

New Information: Josie claims Erin is a reclusive “gamer” who regressed to eating baby food.

Chapter 27: The Cupboard and Art (Monday, 15 July)

While Alix is on the school run, Josie investigates the house and steals a child’s drawing and photos of Leon.

She discovers a sofa‑bed in the study and realizes she doesn’t have to leave the house on Saturday.

Josie records a story about Walter grooming Roxy’s friend, Brooke Ripley, and sleeping with her in Josie’s bed.

She claims this is why Roxy ran away.

A documentary segment features gamers who witnessed “Erased” (Erin) being attacked during a live stream.

They heard screaming and banging before the feed went dead.

Alix finds Josie’s demeanor unnervingly “happy” despite her alleged trauma.

Key Moment: Josie decides she will not leave Alix’s house despite being asked to.

New Information: Erin was a famous streamer known as “Erased” who vanished mid‑broadcast.

Part III

Chapter 28: Scatological Incidents and Brooke (Tuesday, 16 July)

Josie’s dog, Fred, has a bout of liquid diarrhea all over Alix’s kitchen floor.

Josie blames the hummus they ate, but Alix is disgusted by the mess and the smell.

Nathan is increasingly vocal about wanting Josie gone by Saturday night.

Alix finds a “blood‑smeared key” with the number 6 while changing Josie’s bedsheets.

She hides it back under the mattress, terrified of what it implies.

Harry reveals to Alix that Brooke Ripley went missing years ago and had a “toxic” fight with Roxy.

Alix finds Facebook posts from Brooke’s aunt about her disappearance after a school prom.

Key Moment: Alix finds the physical evidence of the blood‑smeared key, confirming a violent secret.

New Information: Brooke Ripley has been a missing person since 2014.

Chapter 29: The Bloodied Key (Wednesday, 17 July)

Alix attempts to reclaim her “normal” by going to a park café, but feels Josie has “swallowed” her life.

She walks past Josie’s flat and notices it looks oddly like a rental ready for new occupants.

There is no sign of Walter, despite Josie claiming he never goes out.

During their recording, Josie refuses to let Alix contact Brooke Ripley, claiming she “doesn’t trust her.”

Alix realizes that Josie is “shutting down” whenever she asks about Erin’s safety.

Josie steals a business card from Nathan’s desk and a plastic bread‑bag tag from the kitchen.

Josie’s manipulative “mentoring” of Alix against Nathan intensifies.

Key Moment: Alix discovers Josie’s flat appears abandoned, contradicting her “violent husband at home” story.

New Information: Josie is using her sister’s card to rent a car and empty bank accounts.

Chapter 30: The Framing of Nathan (Thursday, 18 July)

While Alix is out, Josie ransacks Nathan’s business jackets and finds a bag of cocaine residue.

She also finds a napkin with a girl’s name and a hotel key card sleeve for “The Railings.”

She keeps these items to plant as evidence of his infidelity.

Josie confronts Nathan in the garden, telling him he should be a “better husband.”

She is furious to learn that Alix’s sisters are definitely sleeping over.

Josie claims she will go to her mother’s on Saturday, but she is secretly coordinating with Katelyn.

Alix notices plot holes in Josie’s story about the night Walter “attacked” her.

Key Moment: Josie collects physical evidence to destroy Alix’s faith in Nathan.

New Information: Josie hired an actress, Katelyn, to lure Nathan to a hotel for a thousand pounds.

Chapter 31: Departure and The Hunt (Saturday, 20 July – Day)

Josie wakes for her last morning in Alix’s house, showering in her herbal shampoo and wearing her pajamas one last time.

She leaves Alix’s home with a “thick reassuring weight” of cash and Alix’s green‑framed sunglasses.

Alix feels a “small shadow” remain after Josie departs and checks under the guest bed.

She retrieves the bloodied key and puts it in her pocket, knowing it means something dark.

Nathan leaves for a night out with friends, promising Alix he will be home by midnight.

Josie follows Nathan to Kilburn tube station, disguised in a Sainsbury’s hat and red lipstick.

She watches him meet his “pack” of friends at a pub in Soho.

Key Moment: Josie leaves Alix’s house and immediately begins stalking Nathan to Soho.

New Information: Josie has been withdrawing thousands of pounds from Erin’s account all week.

Chapter 32: The Soho Trap (Saturday, 20 July – Night)

Katelyn approaches Nathan and his friends at the Lamb & Flag, pretending she was stood up by a friend.

Nathan is hyperaware of the beautiful young woman and invites her to stay with the group.

Josie watches from a nearby restaurant as Nathan drinks heavily and celebrates being rid of the “houseguest from hell.”

Katelyn eventually lures Nathan away from his friends to the pre‑booked hotel room.

Meanwhile, Alix finds the planted cocaine, hotel card, and “Daisy” napkin in her shoe rack.

She is devastated, believing her husband has been cheating and using drugs.

Katelyn locks Nathan in the room and sprays perfume to make it look like a sexual encounter.

Key Moment: Nathan is successfully lured into a hotel room by Katelyn as part of Josie’s trap.

New Information: Josie’s “Daisy” napkin was a calculated detail to set off “alarm bells” for Alix.

Chapter 33: Paranoia and Confirmation (Sunday, 21 July)

Alix spends a sleepless night in “alcohol‑induced paranoia” and dread.

She visits Nathan’s friend Giovanni, who eventually admits Nathan left a bar with a woman named Katelyn.

Alix feels a “slick of bitter bile” as she confirms Nathan was with a stranger.

Nathan remains missing throughout the day, and his phone stays off.

Josie messages Katelyn at 3 A.M. to “send him out” to the waiting car.

CCTV shows Nathan getting into a car rented by “Erin Jade Fair.”

Josie smiles as she drives him away, having successfully “rescued” him for Alix.

Key Moment: Alix confirms Nathan was with another woman, while CCTV captures his kidnapping.

New Information: Nathan was too drunk to message Alix; Katelyn took over his phone to lie to him.

Part IV

Chapter 34: The Trashed Room and CCTV (Monday, 22 July)

The hotel calls Alix to report Nathan’s room has been “trashed” and his card was declined.

Alix visits room 18 and finds blood, sign of a struggle, and a discarded thong.

CCTV footage shows Nathan stumbling out of the hotel at 3 A.M. and smiling as he enters the Kia.

Alix discovers the car was rented using Erin Fair’s card.

She calls the deputy commissioner of police, an old podcast guest, to trace the plates.

Neighbors at Manor Park Road tell police of “loud screams” over a week ago.

Police find Walter Fair’s decomposing body in the bathtub and Erin Fair tied up in a storage cupboard, barely alive.

Key Moment: The gruesome reality of the Fair household is uncovered by the police.

New Information: Walter was murdered and Erin was tortured by Josie before Josie ever arrived at Alix’s door.

Chapter 35: Evidence Table (Wednesday, 24 July)

DC Sabrina Albright invites Alix to the station to identify stolen items found in Josie’s drawer.

Alix sees her Nespresso pod, soap, and bracelet alongside items belonging to Brooke Ripley.

She identifies a photo of Brooke with her half‑siblings and a corsage from Brooke’s prom night.

Alix tells the police about the blood‑smeared key Josie left under her mattress.

She realizes with horror that Leon’s passport photos were “nestling in amongst Josie’s sad, faded underwear.”

There is no sign of Alix’s golden bumblebee pendant.

Alix’s mother tries to reassure her that Nathan will show up by the weekend.

Key Moment: Alix connects the missing Brooke Ripley to the Fair household via the stolen items.

New Information: Josie had been keeping “trophies” of Brooke Ripley for over five years.

Chapter 36: Roxy and Pat Speak (Thursday, 25 July)

Roxy Fair returns from Bristol and tells the police that Walter never abused them.

She reveals Walter was “Pops,” a beloved gaming partner who helped monetize Erin’s stream.

Roxy describes Josie as “sick with envy” and jealous of any affection Walter showed his daughters.

She also admits that she and Brooke Ripley were lovers, and Brooke disappeared the night Roxy ran away.

Pat O’Neill confirms that she had an affair with Walter when Josie was thirteen.

Pat claims Josie “snatched” Walter away from her as an act of pure stone‑heartedness.

Roxy mentions a dusty garage Walter leased that might match the “number 6” key.

Key Moment: Roxy shatters Josie’s false narrative, revealing Josie’s pathological jealousy.

New Information: Walter was actually a “loving man” who supported his daughters’ independence.

Chapter 37: The Lodge and Death (Sunday, 28 July)

Police find Nathan Summer’s body in the shallow waters of Lake Windermere.

He died from a barbiturate overdose because Josie “gave him too much” to keep him quiet.

Just before the body is found, Josie sends Alix a final voice message.

She claims she meant to show Alix how “better her life could be without him” but it “went wrong.”

She calls Alix her only friend and asks her to tell the world she isn’t evil.

The “blood‑smeared key” opens a garage where Brooke Ripley’s remains are found in a car boot.

Brooke was wearing her white prom dress, which disintegrates upon touch.

Key Moment: Nathan is found dead, and Josie makes a final, delusional plea to Alix.

New Information: Josie killed Brooke Ripley years ago and Walter helped hide the body to protect the family.

Chapter 38: Aftermath: Funerals and Podcasts (January 2022)

Nathan’s funeral is attended by three hundred people, highlighting how much he was loved.

Alix wears an “artichoke” green dress to match his eyes and eventually collapses in grief.

Months later, during the pandemic, Alix turns the hours of recordings into a viral true‑crime podcast.

She interviews Katelyn, who apologizes profusely for her part in the “sisterhood” scheme.

Katelyn confirms Nathan spent his final free hours talking about how much he loved Alix.

The podcast becomes a Netflix documentary titled *Hi! I’m Your Birthday Twin!*.

Alix replaces the stolen items in her home, finding a “strange satisfaction” in reclaiming her life.

Key Moment: Alix turns her trauma into professional success, branding Josie an “evil basic bitch.”

New Information: Nathan was fundamentally decent and only drank to self‑medicate his own grief.

Chapter 39: Final Word (March 2022)

In November 2020, Alix receives a letter from Josie accusing her of turning her “truth” into tacky true crime.

Josie insists Nathan’s death was an accident and that Roxy and Erin are the real liars.

By March 2022, Josie is living in a Midlands city with dyed blond hair and a face mask.

She listens to women on a bus discuss the Netflix documentary, finding the story “creepy as fuck.”

Josie strokes the stolen bumblebee pendant and rationalizes her crimes as acts of a “true mother.”

She remembers finding Roxy over Brooke’s body, though it is implied this is her final delusion.

The novel ends with Josie unrepentant, convinced she has done nothing wrong.

Key Moment: Josie remains free and deluded, continuing to rewrite her reality.

New Information: Josie is still wearing Alix’s stolen bumblebee pendant as her final trophy.

A Similar Next Read: The Anniversary Summary – Alex Finlay 

More Lisa Jewell Book Summaries

1. I Found You Summary | Lisa Jewell
2. The Night She Disappeared Summary
3. The Girls in the Garden Summary Every Thriller Fan Needs
4. Then She Was Gone Summary
5. Ralph’s Party Summary,
6. Don’t Let Him In Summary