Wish You Were Here Summary: An Unforgettable Pandemic Twist
The book follows Diana O’Toole during the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Her life is interrupted by a trip that never really happens.
TL;DR: The Illusion of Escape
Diana O’Toole plans a trip to the Galápagos with her boyfriend Finn. When Finn stays behind to work in a New York hospital, Diana goes alone.
Stranded on Isabela Island, she builds a new life and falls for a local man named Gabriel. Then she wakes up in a hospital bed.
The entire island experience was a hallucination while she fought COVID-19 on a ventilator. The novel follows her physical recovery and her decision to rebuild her real life.
Wish You Were Here Summary: The Deep Dive
Major spoilers ahead. This section reveals the full plot including the ending.
Diana O’Toole works at Sotheby’s auction house in New York. She is thirty years old and expects a marriage proposal from her boyfriend, Finn Colson, a surgical resident.
The COVID-19 pandemic begins shutting down the city. Finn cannot travel, so Diana takes their planned trip to the Galápagos Islands alone.
On Isabela Island, the world locks down. Ferries stop running, and Diana loses her luggage.
She is taken in by an elderly woman named Abuela.
Read Also: Whistler by Ann Patchett Summary: A Soulful Tale of Memory & Lost Fathers
Diana meets Abuela’s granddaughter, Beatriz, a teenager struggling with self-harm.
Diana also meets Gabriel, Beatriz’s father, a former guide now farming on the island. Over time, Diana adjusts to the rugged landscape and slower pace.
She bonds with Beatriz and begins a romance with Gabriel. Through intermittent emails, Finn describes the horrors of overcrowded hospitals in New York.
Diana feels both removed from and guilty about the suffering. Her island life reaches a peak when she and Gabriel admit their love.
During a swim, Diana is caught in a riptide and drowns. At the moment of death, she wakes up in a New York hospital.
Diana never left the city. She collapsed in her apartment and spent ten days on a ventilator with severe COVID-19.
The island, Gabriel, Beatriz, and Abuela were all part of ICU psychosis. Her brain created a vivid, three-dimensional alternate reality.
The remainder of the novel follows her physical recovery. She must relearn basic movements like sitting and walking.
Her relationship with Finn becomes strained. He witnessed death daily while she lived inside her own mind.
Diana’s mother, Hannah, has Alzheimer’s disease. Hannah dies from COVID-19 after a final moment of clarity with Diana.
Diana realizes her planned life was not what she wanted. She leaves Finn and quits her job at Sotheby’s.
She trains to become an art therapist. Three years later, she travels to the real Isabela Island.
The novel ends with Diana meeting a man who looks exactly like Gabriel from her hallucination.
Read Also: The People We Keep Summary: A Deeply Divisive Coming‑of‑Age Story
Summary by Chapter
Spoiler warning: This section covers chapter events in detail.
The Inciting Incident and Island Arrival (Chapters 1–3)
Diana leaves New York just as the pandemic escalates. She arrives on Isabela Island and is immediately stranded by a strict lockdown.
She meets Abuela, who gives her shelter and food. The island feels alien and prehistoric compared to her structured Manhattan life.
Connections and Contrasts (Chapters 4–6)
Diana grows close to Beatriz and learns about her self-harm. Meanwhile, Finn’s emails describe refrigerated trucks used as morgues.
The contrast between paradise and pandemic sharpens. Diana feels like a fugitive from the world’s suffering.
The Peak of the Dream and the Drowning (Chapters 7–11)
Diana and Gabriel fall in love. Diana experiences a broken video call suggesting her mother has died.
She goes swimming with Gabriel and is caught in a riptide. Her drowning in the hallucination forces her back to consciousness.
Explore Also: Enormous Wings Summary by Laurie Frankel
The Harsh Awakening (Chapters 12–14)
Diana wakes in a COVID ward. She learns her months on the island were only ten days on a ventilator.
She must accept that Gabriel and Beatriz never existed. Physical therapy becomes her new full-time job.
Confronting Reality and Choosing a New Path (Chapters 15–18)
Diana’s mother dies from the virus. Diana’s relationship with Finn ends as she recognizes her old life was a cage.
She leaves Sotheby’s to pursue art therapy. The epilogue shows her arriving on Isabela Island for real.
Characters In This Book
| Character | Role |
|---|---|
| Diana O’Toole | Sotheby’s associate who rebuilds her life after a near-fatal illness. |
| Finn Colson | Surgical resident and Diana’s boyfriend who works through the pandemic in New York. |
| Gabriel Fernandez | Galapagueño farmer and former guide who exists only in Diana’s hallucination. |
| Beatriz | Gabriel’s teenage daughter in the hallucination who struggles with self-harm. |
| Abuela | Gabriel’s grandmother who shelters Diana on Isabela Island. |
| Hannah O’Toole | Diana’s mother, a photojournalist with early-onset Alzheimer’s. |
| Rodney | Diana’s colleague and best friend at Sotheby’s. |
| Kitomi Ito | A Sotheby’s client and mentor figure to Diana. |
What Drives the Story
| Theme | How the book presents it |
|---|---|
| Isolation and Loneliness | Diana is stranded on Isabela Island and later isolated in a hospital room. |
| Adaptation and Natural Selection | The Galápagos setting mirrors Diana’s forced adaptation to a new reality. |
| The Subjectivity of Reality | A vivid hallucination feels more real to Diana than her actual life. |
| Grief and Loss | Diana loses her mother, her relationship, and her planned future. |
| The Burden of Planning | Diana’s detailed life plan collapses under unexpected events. |
| Resilience in Crisis | Characters survive pandemic trauma, illness, and personal collapse. |
Read Also: Handle with Care Book Summary – Marybeth Mayhew Whalen
FAQ
What happens at the ending of Wish You Were Here?
The ending shows Diana three years after her illness. She has become an art therapist and travels to Isabela Island for real. The final scene introduces a man who looks exactly like Gabriel from her dream.
Is the Galápagos trip in Wish You Were Here real?
No, the entire Galápagos trip is a hallucination caused by ICU psychosis. Diana was in a New York hospital on a ventilator the whole time. Her brain constructed the island narrative from memories and desires.
Does Diana end up with Finn in Wish You Were Here?
Diana and Finn break up after her recovery. Their relationship cannot survive the separate traumas they endured. Diana chooses to leave her old life behind.
What genre is Wish You Were Here?
The novel is contemporary fiction with psychological and medical elements. It fits the pandemic fiction subgenre. It also includes a strong thread of literary introspection.
Read Also: The Great Believers Summary – Rebecca Makkai
About Jodi Picoult
Jodi Picoult is an American author known for novels that tackle ethical and social issues. She has written over twenty-five books, many of which became bestsellers. Her work often blends family drama with legal, medical, or moral questions.
Picoult co-authored the young adult novel *Between the Lines* with her daughter Samantha van Leer. She lives in New Hampshire.
For more summaries of her books, visit Jodi Picoult book summaries on URSummary.
