Dolly All the Time Summary By Chapter | Annabel Monaghan
Introduction
This Dolly All the Time Summary by Chapter walks you through every turn in Annabel Monaghan’s warm, witty novel about a woman who’s spent her life fixing messes for the people she loves—until a billionaire with a flat tire offers her a deal that changes everything.
It’s a story of class, caregiving, and discovering that sometimes the biggest rescue you can perform is on your own heart.
Book Structure Overview
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Total Chapters | 41 chapters |
| Prologue / Epilogue | None (final chapter includes a “12 Months Later” section) |
| Narrative Flow | Linear, first‑person (Dolly Brick), spanning one life‑changing summer and its aftermath |
Read Also: Love Song Summary: A Heartbreaking Reunion | Elle Kennedy
Dolly All the Time Summary Chapter by Chapter
⚠️ Spoiler Warning: This section contains detailed, chapter-by-chapter plot summaries.
Chapter 1: The Return to Whitfield
Dolly Brick juggles a fitness call‑center side hustle while helping at her father’s fish house. She’s back in Whitfield, Rhode Island, because a fire—triggered by a neglected alarm battery she usually replaces—broke out at her dad’s place. Determined to assess the living situation of her father Freddie and brother Christopher, she plans to stay for the summer.
Four generations of Bricks have worked the fish house, and Dolly slides right back into the familiar rhythms. While delivering shrimp to the grand Whitfield estate, Eight Oaks, she thinks about her mother’s abandonment years before. On the ride back, she spots a man next to a black Range Rover with a flat tire.
The stranded man is Stewart Whitfield, the billionaire heir, helpless with a dead phone and no idea how to change a tire. Dolly mocks his uselessness but expertly swaps it out herself. In that single dusty encounter, their two worlds collide.
Chapter 2: The $50,000 Problem
Back at the family home on Goose Lane, Dolly cleans obsessively to regain control. She reunites with Christopher, who needs constant care after a childhood head injury. Her best friend Naomi visits for dinner, and Dolly recounts the hilarious tire‑changing story, showing off Stewart’s monogrammed handkerchief.
The laughter ends when Fire Chief Gavin McCumber arrives for an inspection. The fire damage was minor, but the roof is original, rotted, and full of mold. Replacing it will cost $50,000—money the Bricks simply don’t have.
If the roof isn’t replaced, the house will be condemned. Freddie suggests maybe they could move, but Dolly refuses to let Christopher lose the only home he knows. She silently vows to find a way, no new debt, no surrender.
Chapter 3: The Proposal
Dolly wakes on the musty sleeping porch and bakes banana bread to soothe her family. She adds “DIY a whole roof” to her frantic to‑do list, desperate for a miracle. Later, Stewart Whitfield corners her on Main Street, brandishing a copy of the New York Post.
The paper features a photo of her changing his tire, with a headline falsely declaring her his new girlfriend. Stewart explains his sister planted the story to mask the fact his fiancée left him very publicly. To secure the CEO promotion, he needs his family to believe he has a stable personal life.
He asks Dolly to pretend to be his girlfriend for a couple of months, offering payment for her time. Dolly impulsively names her price: $60,000—the roof cost plus a cushion. Stewart agrees instantly. Dolly realizes she might have just landed the strangest fourth side hustle of her life.
Chapter 4: The Strategy Session
Dolly rushes to Naomi’s tourist shop to share the insane news. Naomi is ecstatic, insisting Stewart must be a great kisser based on his photos—a detail Dolly finds completely irrelevant. They hide in the back room to discuss the morality of it, but the $60,000 is too life‑changing to refuse.
Stewart texts, confirming his seriousness and asking Dolly to meet at his Eight Oaks office. Dolly refuses, afraid of the “butler and the show” before she understands the rules. Naomi seizes Dolly’s phone and negotiates a dinner meeting at a dark, sexy restaurant in a neighboring town.
The two women spend the afternoon laughing at the absurdity of Dolly “summering” with yachts and crystal figurines. Dolly worries how her son Gus will react. Naomi reminds her this is Dolly’s chance to finally be swept off her feet, even if it’s all pretend.
Chapter 5: Terms and Conditions
Dolly drives to Bistro Belle Vie in a 1990s dress she found in her sister’s closet. Stewart arrives looking too handsome and is surprised she never uses exclamation points in texts. They sit down with a laptop to formalize their contract, complete with an NDA Stewart insists upon.
Stewart explains his rival cousin Grant is also up for CEO, and Grant’s happy marriage makes Stewart look unstable. They agree on two outings per week, a strict “no touching” policy except in public photo ops, and a fabricated meet‑cute involving bikes and Boston Common.
Stewart eyes her outdated dress and offers a clothing allowance. He hands Dolly a check for $30,000 as a down payment, officially beginning the bizarre arrangement. Walking her to the car, he makes an awkward attempt at a couple‑like pat on her shoulder that leaves Dolly bemused.
Chapter 6: Operation Makeover Begins
Dolly returns home to find Gus watching TV and wrestles with the urge to tell him everything. She spends the night at her grandmother’s sewing machine, repairing the sleeping porch and mulling over Stewart’s relentless workaholism. Stewart texts that his sister, Busy, wants to take her shopping on Monday.
Dolly is intimidated by Busy’s socialite reputation but agrees. Naomi begs to come along as backup. The contrast between Dolly’s four‑job reality and Stewart’s world of remote work and yachts sharpens. She begins to grasp that maintaining this lie will demand more than a performance—it will be a total immersion into a different class.
Chapter 7: Coming Clean to Dad
Over zucchini muffins, Dolly decides to tell her father the truth. She shows him the $30,000 check and explains she’s Stewart’s “pretend girlfriend” to help his image. Freddie Brick hates every single thing about it, worried his daughter is sacrificing too much of herself again.
Dolly insists that eating fancy food and wearing mascara isn’t sacrifice; it’s a miracle that will save their home. Freddie reluctantly accepts the money but warns her about the emotional toll of the deception. Dolly knows she still has to tell Gus, but Christopher can’t keep a secret, so she dreads the town finding out.
Chapter 8: The Transformation
Dolly meets Busy Whitfield at a high‑end boutique called Wendell’s. Busy is like a walking glass of champagne, thrilled to help “poor Stewart.” They spend the day trying on low‑key whimsical clothes, drinking champagne, and eating shrimp.
Dolly feels like a peacock in canary yellow pants and a celery‑green satin gown for an upcoming gala. She’s fitted with a dahlia necklace fashioned from gold. Then Busy and Naomi whisk her to a salon for a dramatic bob haircut.
Dolly feels exposed, vulnerable, and lighter all at once. The woman staring back from the mirror is chic and almost unrecognizable. The physical transformation marks her official entry into Stewart Whitfield’s orbit.
Chapter 9: The Plot Twist
Dolly returns home with her new hair and shopping bags, baffling Christopher and worrying Gus. Christopher loathes the haircut; Gus is suspicious of the sudden luxury. Dolly takes Gus for ice cream and tells him the entire truth: the fire, the roof, the $60,000, and the fake girlfriend scheme.
To her immense relief, Gus finds the whole thing “crazy” and “cool,” joking that he wishes he could pretend to be a Red Sox player for a summer. His support lifts a weight off Dolly’s shoulders. She still feels the secret pressing on her, but now she has a confidant in her son.
Chapter 10: The Providence Gala
Stewart picks up Dolly in a chauffeured car for their first public event, a cancer fundraiser where he’s being honored. Terrified, she bounces her leg in the back seat while Stewart stays cold and phone‑focused. Dolly demands a compliment to “save her life,” and he admits she’s wearing everything very well.
At the party, Dolly flounders in high‑society small talk and accidentally mentions Princess Diana is dead during a conversation about royal couples. She flees to the restroom and encounters Jen, the cancer center head, whose couture gown strap just broke. Dolly whips out her emergency sewing kit and repairs it, earning Jen’s eternal gratitude.
Stewart gives a moving speech about his sister Busy’s childhood cancer, surprising Dolly. On the drive home, they practice “intimate” hand‑holding, and a genuine spark flickers between them.
Chapter 11: The Next Move
Flirty texts start flying between Dolly and Stewart while she’s at work. He suggests a meeting to go over basic facts about each other so they can fool his parents. Dolly refuses to meet at his office again and counters with his boat—for “fun” and “Vitamin D.”
Stewart resists leisure but Dolly holds him to the deal. Meanwhile, Gus texts that he’s made a new friend, Clay, while clamming. Dolly is overjoyed; her son is finally finding his place in Whitfield. She realizes this strange summer is reshaping Gus’s life as much as her own.
Chapter 12: Preparing for the Yacht
Dolly and Gus wash dishes while pretending to take medical calls on bananas—a rare moment of pure levity. She tells Gus they’re going on Stewart’s yacht the next day and impulsively asks if Gus and Clay can tag along. Stewart agrees without hesitation.
Naomi arrives at 8 a.m. with a turquoise bikini, insisting Dolly’s “perfectly good” suit won’t cut it for a Whitfield. Dolly describes herself as a Comfort Inn—reliable and safe—while Stewart is a Four Seasons. Naomi rejects the metaphor, calling Dolly the Ritz‑Carlton.
Chapter 13: The Secret Grotto
Stewart picks up Dolly, Gus, and Clay in his vintage green Range Rover, and Dolly’s nervous when he compliments her thighs. They board Marian, a beautiful wooden sailboat, and head to Ruddy Duck Cove. Stewart is a businesslike captain, and Dolly enjoys watching him work.
He lets Dolly take the helm, promising to be her backup. While the boys go clamming, Stewart leads Dolly through a dark cave into a secret open‑air grotto with a waterfall. They swim together, and an intense physical attraction hums between them.
Dolly tells Stewart about Gus’s father, Niles, who gave her $300 and walked away. Stewart’s visible anger on her behalf reveals a growing protectiveness that feels far beyond a contract.
Chapter 14: Fending Off Chaos
Relaxing on the beach with a beer, Dolly and Stewart joke about their fake meet‑cute, and Stewart admits he noticed her legs the day she changed his tire. Dolly opens up about her mother, who left when Dolly was twelve and never came back. She explains how she became the caretaker to “fend off the chaos.”
Stewart relates deeply, confessing he works constantly to prevent his family from collapsing after Busy’s childhood illness. They realize they share a caretaker identity, a bone‑deep fear of letting everything fall apart. On the sail back, Stewart patiently teaches Gus and Clay how to tie knots.
Chapter 15: The Image Rehabilitation
The group returns to the Brick house, where Stewart meets Freddie. Stewart’s CEO guard goes up, but Freddie thanks him for the roof money. Stewart insists Dolly is a terrible negotiator—he would have paid more.
Freddie invites Stewart inside to see the roof plans, but Dolly shuts it down, not ready to let him into her private space. After Stewart leaves, Freddie warns Dolly to remember this is just “fun” and a “charade.” Dolly lies to herself, claiming they might even end up friends, but she puts on Stewart’s yachting hat and knows she’s already in too deep.
Chapter 16: Dinner at Eight Oaks
Stewart invites Dolly to dinner with his parents on the west veranda of Eight Oaks. Extremely nervous, she accidentally shows up at the delivery entrance, shrimp gift in hand. Gladys takes the bag with a knowing look.
Dolly meets Victoria and Henry Whitfield, along with rival cousin Grant and his wife Kendall. Kendall is openly condescending about Dolly’s background. Dolly proudly announces she’s Freddie Brick’s daughter and a fish delivery girl, and Stewart defends her.
Noticing Dolly doesn’t like coffee, Stewart insists she ask Gladys for tea with honey. He tells her it’s okay to say what she wants. In that small gesture, Dolly feels seen.
Chapter 17: The Panic Attack
Dinner turns hostile when Grant insults Stewart’s San Francisco project, calling it “old crap.” Henry sides with Grant, questioning Stewart’s leadership. Stewart freezes, expressionless, then abruptly leaves the table.
Dolly finds him in the garden having a severe panic attack. She climbs into his lap, holds him, and guides him through deep breaths until his heart rate slows. Walking through the vegetable garden afterward, Stewart admits his terror of failure and his dread of being the Whitfield who “screwed it all up.”
Dolly sees him as Atlas, carrying his entire family on his shoulders. They almost kiss, but Dolly pulls away, scared by the raw intimacy. The contract is starting to feel dangerously real.
Chapter 18: The Barbecue Invitation
Dolly wakes to a group text from her teacher friends about a new guy, but her mind is on Stewart’s early morning call to “check on his employees”—which she reads as flirty. Freddie, impressed by Stewart’s help, insists on inviting him for a barbecue.
Dolly is reluctant to let Stewart deeper into her personal world but eventually texts the invitation. Stewart accepts instantly and offers to bring wine. She spends the afternoon decorating the porch with wildflowers, trying to pretend she hasn’t “gone mad” with excitement.
Chapter 19: The First Kiss
Stewart arrives at the Brick house with five bottles of wine and a bouquet of herbs. He meets Christopher and Gus again, fitting in better than Dolly expected. He admires her sewing room and suggests she use her leftover $10,000 to renovate it with a fireplace.
During dinner, Stewart and Freddie bond over fish stories and “rich‑guy hair” jokes. Stewart invites Gus and Clay to a Red Sox vs. Yankees game in his private box. The next night, he takes Dolly on a sunset cruise.
Below deck, Stewart admits he thinks about kissing her all the time. When their lips finally meet, it’s delicious and endless. Dolly panics afterward and labels it “method acting” to protect her heart.
Chapter 20: The Silent Week
Stewart goes to New York for business and texts an apology if the kiss upset her. Dolly replies she’s fine and it was good to “go there for a minute,” but days of silence follow. A thunderstorm sends water through the kitchen roof, forcing emergency repairs.
Dolly’s sister Patsy calls, shocked to hear Dolly is “dating Stewart Whitfield.” A ripple of resentment surfaces—Dolly always handles the crises alone. At night, she dreams of Stewart and waits for his return, realizing he has infiltrated her thoughts completely.
Chapter 21: The Backup
A double crisis hits: Christopher cracks a tooth on butterscotch, and Gus hits his head at lifeguard camp. Trapped at the dentist with a furious Christopher, Dolly is overwhelmed. Stewart calls at the worst possible moment, but when he hears the chaos, he immediately leaves work to pick up Gus.
He brings Gus to Eight Oaks, where his mother Victoria treats the injury. Dolly arrives to find Stewart and Gus playing backgammon. She’s moved to tears—Stewart has become her backup. Gus announces he thinks his mom “like‑likes” Stewart.
Chapter 22: Operation Payback
Busy organizes a lunch at the yacht club she dubs “Operation Payback,” designed to show Dolly off to Audrey’s old friends. Dolly wears her extroverted yellow pants, feeling costumed. Naomi warns her she’s in code‑red territory and genuinely falling.
Busy notes Stewart and Dolly are holding hands and that Stewart seems lighter, happier. Stewart texts Gus to set up a private sailing lesson. Watching Stewart teach her son on the water, Dolly feels her tragically low expectations for men begin to shift.
Chapter 23: The Boston Invitation
Stewart visits the fish house and asks Dolly to accompany him to Boston for an overnight trip. A critical dinner with the Kramer clients hinges on proving the company is behind his San Francisco project, and he tells Dolly she just “helps him” and he wants her in his corner.
Dolly panics over the intimacy of an overnight but agrees. Gus asks her to grab his favorite Red Sox sweatshirt from their Boston apartment while she’s there. She realizes she’s about to step into Stewart’s real life on Beacon Hill.
Chapter 24: The BOGO Dinner
They travel to Boston by helicopter, leaving Dolly anxious, excited, and giddy. Before dinner, Stewart shows her his corner office, where the telescope is trained on Fenway Park. At the client dinner, Stewart is masterful and sexy, but Henry Whitfield continues to criticize the project.
Dolly saves the meeting by sharing a story about happy memories at Addie’s Ice Cream, persuading the clients of the value in preserving history. She then charms everyone by teaching Stewart and Henry about BOGO deals. Henry laughs for the first time, and the deal is sealed.
Chapter 25: The Beacon Hill Night
After dinner, Stewart takes Dolly to his three‑story brick Beacon Hill mansion. She’s overwhelmed by the books‑filled den and a painting that seems alive. Stewart fusses through six cupboards to find her tea, a gesture that moves her deeply.
They drive to Dolly’s modest Brighton apartment in his vintage Jaguar. Stewart asks to come inside because he wants to see her real life. He admires the quilt she made for Gus and tells her she’s a great mother.
All pretenses drop. They make love for the first time, and Stewart confesses he hasn’t gotten her out of his system. He asks Dolly to raise her expectations for him.
Chapter 26: The Beacon Hill Morning
Dolly wakes in Stewart’s bed to find him bringing her tea with honey. They spend the day in his den, Dolly researching commercial ovens for a bakery she dreams of opening at the fish house. Stewart works but frequently stops to kiss her.
They feel like a real couple for the first time, and the housekeeper Helena smiles at the “pleasant shock.” Back in Whitfield, Freddie notices Dolly’s swollen lips and warns her that Stewart is an awfully big catch for a Brick. Dolly insists it’s just fun, but she knows it’s soulful and explosive.
Chapter 27: The Good Seats
Stewart takes Dolly, Gus, and Clay to a Red Sox vs. Yankees game, surprising them with front‑row seats on the third‑base line. Dolly’s sister sees them on TV and texts in shock, forcing Dolly to invent a lame raffle story.
Stewart buys everyone gear and turns Gus’s cap backward, a fatherly gesture that squeezes Dolly’s heart. Gus catches them holding hands and tells Dolly he likes Stewart too. Dolly realizes she’s no longer pushing back against the good seats—she’s letting herself enjoy this world.
Chapter 28: Porch Dreams
The roof construction continues, and Dolly and Stewart see each other every single day. Evenings on his boat are spent sketching plans for her renovated sleeping porch with a stone fireplace. Stewart gives Gus sailing lessons, and Dolly watches her son’s confidence bloom.
Stewart tells Dolly he never thought he could be this happy. He makes plans for a September Red Sox game, pointing toward a future after summer. Naomi insists Dolly bring Stewart to the local bar, Peepers, so everyone can witness them together.
Chapter 29: Drinks at Peepers
Dolly meets Naomi and Sully at Peepers, full‑body smiling when Stewart arrives in pink, looking too handsome. He charms her friends and talks about living in Boston full‑time once the summer ends. Under the streetlights, they feel like a world of their own.
They walk back to Goose Lane and sit on the porch swing with chamomile tea and crickets. Stewart mentions Gus wants to take over the fish house someday—a dream her son hadn’t shared with Dolly. Stewart is weaving himself into the fabric of her family.
Chapter 30: The Final Week
Stewart goes to San Francisco for the Kramer project, and they miss each other a dangerous amount. Texting constantly, Stewart wishes Dolly were there. Freddie preps the Starlight Gala—the fish house’s biggest order of the year—and Gus and friends crack lobsters in the Whitfield garage.
The official end of the contract is near, but Dolly feels secure in Stewart’s love. She feels bedazzled from the inside out as the gala approaches, certain forever is in sight.
Chapter 31: Just Us
Stewart returns from San Francisco and asks for “dinner, just us.” They reunite at Eight Oaks with an intense, emotional intimacy that feels like removing the last barrier. Stewart admits being apart for a week was torture and he missed Dolly desperately.
He tells her he’s been waiting his whole life to feel like this and would change the world to keep her. Dolly is terrified by how happy she is, fearing it’s too good to be true. They promise to circle back to future plans after the gala, both knowing the fake is long dead.
Chapter 32: The Gala Betrayal
The Starlight Gala begins, and Dolly is radiant in her white princess dress. Everything is perfect until Grant interrupts their dance. Henry Whitfield appears, fuming, and accuses Stewart of hiring a “call girl.” Grant found the $60,000 contract in Stewart’s briefcase.
Stewart is paralyzed by panic and his fear of his father’s disapproval. He fails to defend Dolly, instead mumbling about poor judgment. Henry walks away disgusted, and Stewart follows, leaving Dolly alone in the crowd.
Dolly removes her dahlia necklace, hands it to Busy, and exits through the delivery entrance. She finds Stewart in the driveway, but he is frozen, saying he doesn’t know what this means for them. He says he’ll drop by with a check.
Chapter 33: The Fallout
Dolly returns home and tries to hide her shattered heart from her family, but she can’t stop crying. She tells Gus the arrangement is simply over. Naomi stays in bed to comfort her, but Dolly is sinking into a dark pit of grief.
She waits for a text or call that never comes. When she finally texts about the board call, Stewart’s reply is short, formal, and ends with a period—a deliberate shut‑out. A messenger delivers the final $30,000 check with no note. Stewart has returned to his Tin Man self.
Chapter 34: Moving On
Contractor Izzy informs Dolly that the stone fireplace and windows for the sleeping porch were delivered and paid for in full by Stewart as a surprise. Dolly is heartbroken—he knew her soul but left anyway. The summer ends, and she and Gus return to Boston, disoriented.
Dolly decides she won’t go back to who she was. She trims her own hair and starts wearing her yellow pants to work. The sleeping porch becomes a beautiful, aching reminder of the life Stewart promised and then retracted.
Chapter 35: The Crisis
In December, unable to stay away from Whitfield’s peace, Dolly and Gus move back full‑time. On New Year’s Day, Gus develops a dangerously high fever and is rushed to the ER. The attending doctor is Victoria Whitfield.
Victoria acts swiftly, diagnosing meningitis and starting IV antibiotics. Dolly breaks down, reflecting on her mother’s abandonment and her rage at Stewart’s easy departure. Victoria comforts her, saying everyone’s a mess when it comes to their kids. Dolly vows she’s done making everyone’s shitty behavior okay.
Chapter 36: Tea and Truth
In January, Dolly runs into Victoria at the grocery store. Victoria invites her for tea at Eight Oaks, and they meet in the cozy library. Victoria admits she knew the relationship started fake but saw it turn genuinely loving.
She reveals Stewart is back to working around the clock, thinner and miserable, trying to prove himself to the board. She calls his abandonment of Dolly a “very weak move” and apologizes as his mother. Dolly admits she’s still angry and wants to yell at him.
Chapter 37: Storming the Castle
Dolly and Naomi drive to Boston so Dolly can confront Stewart at his corporate office. She strides into the lobby and demands an appointment, refusing to be intimidated. On the 30th floor, she finds Stewart looking tired and sunken.
She tells him exactly how he broke her heart, calls him pathetic for returning to a job he doesn’t even want, and thanks him for the sleeping porch before storming out. She feels like she’s put down something heavy and finally prioritized herself.
Chapter 38: The Fish House Empire
Dolly leans into her life in Whitfield, expanding the fish house with a bakery counter against her father’s wishes. She starts shipping fish online, with Patsy handling social media, and Christopher becomes more present and helpful. Dolly realizes she’s built the life she always wanted, without Stewart.
In May, delivering salmon to Victoria, she learns Stewart has been watching a lot of TV, working less, and finally asking his father for help—overcoming his Atlas complex. Victoria asks if Dolly would give him another chance. Dolly stays noncommittal.
Chapter 39: The Apology
On the first Saturday of June, Stewart appears at the door of Dolly’s renovated sleeping porch in jeans, looking rested. He apologizes for the gala, admitting that losing the promotion made him realize he didn’t even know who he was without the power.
He reveals that he and Gus have been texting for months about a sailing race and the Red Sox. Stewart tells Dolly he’d walk away from everything to have a life with her. Dolly admits she still loves him but won’t do this “just for a little while.” Stewart promises he will never leave her again.
Chapter 40: The Trial Basis
The next morning, Stewart arrives at the Brick house with peonies to apologize to the whole family. He tells Gus and Freddie he loves Dolly and wants their permission to date her. Gus grants it on a “trial basis,” and Stewart laughs with relief.
Sixteen days later, the entire Brick and Whitfield families set sail for Nantucket on the giant yacht Savannah. Stewart white‑knuckles the helm, terrified of sinking the family ship. Dolly puts her hand over his, promising to be his backup now too.
Chapter 41: Forever
Twelve months later, Dolly and Stewart are building a shared life in Whitfield. Stewart has restructured the company and runs a preservation arm from the local library. Dolly’s bakery at the fish house is thriving.
In the Eight Oaks vegetable garden, Stewart proposes with his great‑grandmother’s ring and asks permission to adopt Gus and become his legal father. Speechless and overwhelmed with joy, Dolly realizes loving Stewart taught her to be put first—and that sharing your life is an act of generosity.
Read Next: The Summer of Second Chances Summary
Stay in the Loop with Book Insights
Enjoy spoiler‑free book snapshots and thoughtful breakdowns? Join our newsletter for carefully curated summaries and insights. The form is in the footer — no spam, just great books. Subscribe here.
Connect With Us
